fbpx

10 Best Broiler Pan For 2021 – Top Rated Picks (Guide)

Best Broiler Pan
Best Broiler Pan

If you are a fan of prepping meat with several different techniques then you probably need a best broiler pan in your kitchen. A broiler is an efficient kitchen utensil that is used to bake meat, sea food, vegetables, turkeys or chickens.

But not all broilers are made to offer expert cooking results. You may have to find the best broiler pan depending on the specs and features that suit your needs.

In the given article we have discussed the points need to consider in a broiler pan along with some of the best broiler pans available in the market.


Related Articles:


List of Top 10 Best Broiler Pan

Product Features Buy On
1. Whirlpool Porcelain Broiler Pan

Very durable Broiler Pan

Evenly heat distribution mechanism

Comes with Separate roasting tray

Dishwasher safe
Amazon
2. Norpro Stainless steel Broil/Roast Pan Set

Durable

Quick heat distribution system

Included roasting tray

Easy to clean

Dishwasher safe
Amazon
3. Range Kleen Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan

Made with stainless steel
Porcelain coating

Stand up with high heat resistant

Dishwasher safe.
Amazon
4. Frigidaire Range/Stove/Oven Broiler Pan

Porcelain enamel steel core

compatible with Bake, boil, and roast

High heat resistant
Drip tray

Stove and oven safe

Dishwasher safe
Amazon
5. Nordic Ware Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler

Made with Tri-ply construction

Matte finishing

Broil and bake function

Drip tray
Amazon
6. Farberware Bakeware Nonstick Steel Roaster

Heavy-gauge carbon steel built

Comes with interior and exterior nonstick coating

Grill, roast, and bake functions Drip tray

Chrome plated handles
Amazon
7. GE WB48X10056 Genuine OEM Broiler Pan

Large pan
Enameled stainless steel
Drip tray
Non toxic non stick
Dishwasher safe
Amazon
8. Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pan /Broiler pan

Having carbon steel construction

PFOA Free

Can handles large capacity of foods

Drip tray
Amazon
9. GreenPan Chatham Ceramic Nonstick Roasting Pan

Construct with Thermolon nonstick coating

Aluminum body

PTFE, PFOA free

Ergonomically designed handles

Dishwasher safe
Amazon
10. Granite Ware Roaster/Broiler Set

Use Porcelain enameled steel in body

Both broil and grill functions

PTFE and PFOA free

Nonstick glass surface

Dishwasher safe.
Amazon

What Is a Broiler Pan and How To Use It?

What is broiler pan

To understand what a broiler pan is you need to know what broiling is. In simple words, broiling is a method in which food is cooked by directly exposing it to heat.

Many people confused broiling with roasting but in broiling heat is distributed directly from the top of the oven not from the bottom as in roasting.

In broiling food gets cook more quickly compared to roasting.

However broiler pans are available in different materials; but stainless steel and anodized aluminum broiler pans are considered more reliable and durable.

You can also consider cast iron broiler pans or enameled steel pans as well. If you are not into broiling and want to experience it for once you can buy a disposable broiler pan as well.

Cooking in broiler pan may seem difficult but it is relatively simple and easy. Lets find out how you can make the most of your broiler pan.

  • Once you located the broiler put your oven rack on the broiler heating element accordingly. Move your oven rack on the highest position; it will help get maximum heat resulting in properly cooked food.
  • The next thing is to heat the broiler which usually takes 5 to 10 minutes. The food cooks best when the broiler is heated properly; check out the broiler settings available in your oven. Different ovens are provided with different broiler settings.
  • Now its time to broil your food. Remember since the whole setup is too hot; this step needs your proper attention and caution. Take out the broiler rack and place your food on it. Slowly slide it back under or over the broiler; as per the dynamics of your oven.
  • Broiling is an extremely hot cooking method; that means your food will be prepared in 15 to 20 minutes. But all this time you need to keep an eye on your food just to keep it from burning by excessive heat or additional cooking time.

Why You Need Broiler Pan?

A broiler pan is a cookware that is used to make steaks, roasts, various meat, seafood or poultry.

It’s just that unlike a roaster pan a broiler does not carry the excess fats, juices or oils used or released by the food and drains it afterwards.

In such a case where you don’t want to carry the excess fats and grease of the food along you can use a broiler pan.

A broiler uses high heat directly accessed from the flame to cook the food quickly. You cannot achieve such cooking results with baking or roaster pans as they employ indirect heat from the source.

A broiler on the other hand works totally opposite that is why its gives food the perfect char on meats and vegetables. 

Factors to Choose Best Broiler Pan?

There are two crucial factors which cannot be ignored while choosing the best broiler pan for your kitchen.

Although there could be so many factors you may need to look after when you are intended to buy the best broiler pan; but considering only two aspects can be helpful as well. Let’s take a look what are these;

Size

Size is of crucial importance, when it comes choosing the best broiler pan that fits your needs. 

You must be wondering how would you know the correct size as there is a chance that you may get a small broiler pan or end up with extra large broiler pan.

In such case your oven may help you finding the right size. Buy a pan that fits your oven size and shape; like if your oven is round or rectangular buy a broiler pan that has the same shape.

Always measure and consider the dimensions of your oven before purchasing the broiler pan.  

Material

The material of a broiler pan is essential to consider; as different materials response to heat differently. A poor quality material may waste your money and time.

A broiler pan that is made of durable material offers safe and healthier cooking free from toxic effects. 

Low quality pans may get rusty, warp or corrode easily on temperature. A good quality broiler pan is easy to clean without any risk of peeling, flaking or scratch.

There are different kinds available in the market depending on the material; such as stainless steel, carbon steel, anodized aluminum, ceramic and cast iron broiler pans.

However, hard anodized, enameled steel and stainless steel are considered best for broiling.

Broil Vs. Bake Vs. Roast: What’s The Difference?

All the three cooking methods are done in the oven but they are all different following; so as the taste they brought to us.

Baking needs consistent low temperature providing indirect hot air to the food to bake it evenly.

Roasting uses high temperature using indirect heat to cook food.

Broilingis similar to grilling; it needs only top element to cook and brown food quickly on extreme and direct heat.

What Are the Substitutes of Broiler Pan?

There are several options available to be used as a substitute for a broiler pan; however e are going to discuss the most commonly found one option that are not too expensive and easily available in your kitchen.

Roasting Pan

Broiler Pan substitutes

A roasting pan can be a perfect substitute for a broiler pan. Mostly a roasting pan is made of hard anodized aluminum, cast iron, enameled steel and stainless steel; all these materials are known to withstand extremely high temperatures.

If you have a roasting pan at home that is good at holding and conducting then there is no need to spend money on buying a broiler pan.

Cast Iron Pan

Due to its perfect heat conductivity and even heat distribution; cast iron skillet is another good option for substituting the broiler pan.

Once exposed to heat, you never have to worry about unevenly cooked food with cast iron pans.

The best thing about cast iron pans is that they are mostly available in every household; so you don’t need to spend extra to buy a broiler pan.

However, if a lid is not available with your cast iron pan then you can use aluminum foil as a cover to help provide consistent temperature to your food.

Baking Tray

If you are out of the above two options shared above then you can try your baking tray as a broiler pan.

However, it may not be as effective but it may get the job done. Just make sure that your baking tray is able to withstand the high temperatures.

How to Clean Broiler Pan in the Easiest and Hygienic way

  • Separate the pan and the broiler rack to pour lemon juice on both.
  • Now sprinkle the same ratio of baking soda as of lemon juice you just poured on the pan and the broiler grill or rack.
  • Now wait for some time until it starts to appear bubble asa reaction caused by mixing the lemon and baking soda. This mixture will help to cut down the stubborn marks and grease for both the pan and grill.
  • Now after few minutes of reaction, use a soft brush or sponge to scrape off the spices or stains. and wash it with simple tap water.

10 Best Broiler Pan – Reviews With Pros and Cons

1. Whirlpool Porcelain Broiler Pan

Whirlpool Porcelain Broiler Pan

Consisting of a pan and a grid this Whirlpool broiler pan is well equipped for any broiling function with its quick and even heating abilities.

The porcelain finish and durable stainless steel coronet just makes sure the heat absorption but also promotes optimal durability with  easy food release and effortless cleaning.

The non stick porcelain coating keeps the ingredients from sticking to the surface under direct heat and with less oil.

The air circulation through several vented holes keeps the food soft and let the excess oil or grease to easily drain.

The 14-inch surface area of the broiler pan is significantly wider so that you can conveniently place multiple items at the same time.

The specified ridges and splatter safeguard keeps the oven cleans from any consequences of mishandling. Though the porcelain finish is quite easy to clean; however you can dump it in the dishwasher as well.

The separate roasting shelf with a metal grid offers broiling almost any type of food items with convenience.

Pros
  • Durable
  • Quick and even heat distribution
  • Premium non stick
  • Separate roasting tray
  • Dishwasher safe
Cons
  • Not good with high heat

2. Norpro Stainless steel Broil/Roast Pan Set

This Norpro 274 is known for its warp resistant and anti corrode characteristics.

Though it is not a non stick pan but the smooth yet durable stainless steel construction serves enough space and withstands high coking temperature both for broil and roasting with efficient food release.

The perfectly pierced diamond perforations on the metal rack allow excess soup, grease and oil drainage so that you can enjoy less greasy, healthy and fat free meal.

The embossed rectangular prism design with the little holes promote greater air circulation to ensure quick and even heat distribution meanwhile baking and roasting.

This 12-inch small broiler pan with its sleek design and hear wearing built stands out among its peers; perfect for preparing meat, chicken, fish, vegetables and bread.

Though this 12-inch pan is a small broiler pan but is ideal for prepping yet serving for two with convenience.

The absence of non-stick coating or porcelain layer may cause your ingredients to stick; however, you can avoid this by using much oil.

Don’t get deceived by the traditional looks of this broiler pan; constructed with stainless steel the Norpro 274 is perfect to offer both durability and heat conductivity. You can easily throw it in the dishwasher fro quick clean up.

Pros
  • Durable
  • Quick and even heat distribution
  • Premium non stick
  • Separate roasting tray
  • Dishwasher safe
Cons
  • Not good with high heat

3. Range Kleen Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan

Range Kleen Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan

Sold in two pieces this broiler pan set features with a heavy duty and durable stainless steel construction.

These broiler pans efficiently with stand extremely high temperature up to 1,025F without getting warp or corrode.

This compact broiler pan set features with a porcelain non stick coating that in combination with stainless steel ensures superior heat conductivity and effortless release.

The arrangement of porcelain and steel add resilience and longevity to the pans; so that you can opt for dishwasher if you are not into hand washing without having to worry about warp or damage.

The excess oil and food debris can be easily collected through drip pan; keeping you safe from consuming excess fat or grease.

The smaller broiler pan is perfect to entertain small family or serve few friends; the compact size is quite helpful in storing especially in small kitchen spaces or to travel along with it.

Comes at a highly reasonable price this broiler pan is highly recommended and lists among the highly rated broiler pans on the market.

Measures around 12.75×8.5×1.3 inch, this Range Kleen is an ideal broiler pan is an ideal broiler pan for prepping veggies, meat and other different kinds of foods outdoor or indoor to enjoy with your loved pans.

Pros
  • Made with heavy duty stainless steel
  • Porcelain non-stick coating
  • High heat resistant
  • Dishwasher safe.
Cons
  • Discolors after few uses

4. Frigidaire Range/Stove/Oven Broiler Pan

Frigidaire Range/Stove/Oven Broiler Pan

This blue-colored broiler pan is constructed with durable stainless steel core coated with porcelain enamel to add a sleek and greasy non-stick layer that conveniently cook healthy food ensuring quick and easy food release with less grease to add.

The premium quality porcelain in combination with sturdy stainless steel is an anti-warp construction that resists high temperature without getting damage, flak or peel.  

Provided with a size that is good to serve all your needs this ceramic broiler pan is intended for a perfect baking, roasting and broiling experience on almost any stove top.

The long yet wide slits of the pan helps to collect excess oils and food debris from meat, fish or veggies and collect it in the drip free tray.

If you are an individual that is concerned for a healthy diet plan the drip free tray is made right for you.

Resistant to high temperatures the non stick layer provides easy food release and quick clean up; however can be washed in the dishwasher and compatible to different stove tops and oven.

Pros
  • Porcelain enamel steel core
  • Bake, boil, and roast compatible
  • High heat resistant
  • Drip tray
  • Stove and oven safe
  • Dishwasher safe
Cons
  • Prone to scratches

5. Nordic Ware Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler

Nordic Ware Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler

This dual piece broiler pan is among the best’s broiler pans known for camping.

Both the pieces consist of carbon steel core covered with two aluminum layers ensuring faster and even heat distribution across the surface for providing optimum cooking results.

The ribbed broiling rack of the Nordic Ware allows drainage for excess oil and grease.

Both pans have warp resistant, matte non-stick finish that offers efficient food release with less oil or butter makes cleaning a hassle free experience.

This is an ideal broiler pan for different toaster ovens, camping or RV stoves. Though both the pieces are safe to be thrown in the dishwasher; however, suggested by manufacturer for hand washing.

Overall, it is a perfect option for a little family, prepping single or double servings; the compact makes it easy to store.

The handles on both sides offers much convenience and durable grip. Nordic Ware has all the capabilities needed in a heavy duty pan to serve both house hold and professional kitchens.

Pros
  • Tri-ply construction
  • Matte non-stick finish
  • Broil and bake function
  • Drip tray
Cons
  • Not dishwasher safe

6. Farberware Bakeware Nonstick Steel Roaster

Farberware Bakeware Nonstick Steel Roaster

We have also added roasting pan in this list reason is roaster pan not only used for roasting but it can offer broiling features as well.

Compared to others, this flat roasting pan is comparatively more compact but delivers the promised premium level cooking experience.

Ideal for everyday use, the Farberware Bakeware’s roaster and the flat rack has a non-stick interior; that not visibly attractive but is also durable.

Constructed from heavy gauge carbon steel, both roaster and the rack can withstand heat up to 450F so that you can roast, bake or grill without any fear of corrosion and warping.

The chrome plated handles are offer firm grip with comfort and convenience.  The elevated grill helps to get rid of excess grease while broiling make sure to offer healthy fat free food.

Like wise the interior the exterior also consist of durable and reliable non stick finish making it obvious to clean with less effort using mild dishwashing soap as it does not support dishwashing.

Pros
  • Heavy-gauge carbon steel built
  • Non stick interior/ exterior
  • Grill, roast, and bake functions
  • Drip tray
  • Chrome plated handles
Cons
  • Movable handles difficult to carry

7. GE WB48X10056 Genuine OEM Broiler Pan

GE WB48X10056 Genuine OEM Broiler Pan

Designed with enameled stainless steel this broiler pan from General Electric is built to offer durability and performance without compromising the quality and safety concerns.

The broiler pan includes grill and bottom pan; the deep bottom collects the fat from the drippings released by the food to ensure a fat free meal consumption. 

The non stick finish is highly heat resistant and free from hazardous chemicals without carrying any risk of flaking, peeling or releasing toxic fumes on extreme temperatures.

With the dimensions of 18.2×15.7×3 this broiler pan comes with a set of grill and bottom pan; both components are dishwasher safe and provides large space for prepping variety of meals.

The venting slits and small holes at the corner allow to drain excess oil and grease from your foods.

Pros
  • Large pan
  • Enameled stainless steel
  • Drip tray
  • Non toxic non stick
  • Dishwasher safe
Cons
  • Non stick coating is not durable.

8. Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pan /Broiler pan

Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pan /Broiler pan

As we know roasting pan can also perform the task of broiler pan. So, we have listed this item to enjoy roasting and broiling both features of the pan.

This roasting pan with rack by Circulon ranks as the Amazon best-selling roasting pan. This is totally an all-rounder for its functionality and versatility.

Just like baking sheets it is made with heavy duty carbon steel construction that promotes faster and even heat distribution with effortless food release.

Features with premium non stick coating both on the interior and exterior is extremely durable that it doesn’t flack or leach and is free from hazardous chemicals such as PFOA.

So if you are roasting a turkey or prepping lasagna you can easily swipe off the left over grease and food fragments with a gentle soap as dishwashing is not suggested by the manufacturer.

The handy metal rack that clips on to the sides of; keeps the food separate from oil drippings and fats so that you stay on the healthy diet plan without skipping the excess fat consumption.

Or, remove the rack and just use the roasting pan for deep dishes like lasagnas and casseroles!

It is basically considered extra large broiler pan with  17×13 inch roaster rack that is big enough to accommodate turkeys or prep large family dinners weight up to 24 lbs.

The wide dual riveted handles provides durable grip while moving it from the oven to the counter. 

It can easily withstand temperature up to 450F without getting damage or warp.

Pros
  • Carbon steel construction
  • PFOA free non stick coating
  • Wide riveted handles
  • Handles big capacity foods
  • Drip tray
Cons
  • Not dishwasher safe

9. GreenPan Chatham Ceramic Nonstick Roasting Pan

Greenpan chatham is another roasting pan that can easily perform your both tasks of broiling and roasting without any hassle.

Constructed with premium grade hard anodized aluminum that has a ceramic non toxic non stick coating free from PFOA.

PFAS, lead or cadmium.This scratch-resistant body is aluminum body is twice as strong as stainless steel.

Reinforced with diamonds the ceramic non stick coating is set to accomplish all your roasting needs without having to use excess oil nor require any hardship for cleaning up the mess.

The diamond cutting edge coating is scratch resistant and metal utensil safe. The soft edges of the pan ensures drip free pouring helps in keeping the kitchen counter clean from any additional mess.

The hard anodized body of this Green roasting pan is broiler and oven safe sturdy enough to withstand temperature up to 600F without releasing hazardous fumes, flake or peel.

The V shaped roasting rack helps maintain air circulation and keeps the oil remains and excess grease at the bottom.

Ergonomically designed riveted stainless steel handles provides secure and comfortable so that you can easily maneuver from oven to counter top safely.

Cleaning this roasting pan is a breeze; you can either choose to wipe clean with sponge or put it in the dishwasher for saving your time.

Pros
  • Thermolon nonstick coating
  • Scratch resistant aluminum body
  • PTFE, PFOA, lead and cadmium free
  • Ergonomically designed handles
  • Dishwasher safe
Cons
  • Small and uncomfortable handles

10. Granite Ware Roaster/Broiler Set

Granite Ware Roaster/Broiler Set

Manufacturer in US, this granite ware broiler pan is one of the most popular broiler pan exists in the category of extra large broiler pans available in the market.

Made with carbon steel core, that is known for its energy efficient thermal conductivity.

It heats up quickly and evenly even with less heat offer a perfectly cooked food with superior brown finish.

Comes in 2 piece set this 17-inch roasting pan and 16-inch broiler pan comes at an affordable price; makes it perfect for broiling and grilling.

The exterior of the roasting and broiler pan is infused with porcelain to the stainless steel base at 2000F to produce a durable non stick glass surface.

This durable PTFE PFOA free porcelain surface is doesn’t flake or peel; however, may chip if dropped so you need to be extra careful while handling or carrying.

The large holes help to get rid of excess grease and fatty food remains allowing you to enjoy a healthy food.

Overall, it is a dishwasher safe set;however, you can conveniently clean it with hand using soft sponge and dishwashing liquid.

It can withstand temperature up to 500F. The smooth curves available at the shorter sides offers firm grip with much convenience.

Pros
  • Porcelain enameled steel body
  • Broil and grill functions
  • PTFE and PFOA free
  • Durable non stick glass surface
  • Dishwasher safe.
Cons
  • May warp under high heat

Which Broiler Pan Is Best: Our Recommendation?

All the above mentioned broiler pans are so far the best broilers pans available in the market; however, if we have to choose one then we would pick Frigidaire Range Broiler Pan [Buy On Amazon] as the premium range ceramic broiler pan with incredible durability to withstand temperature up to 500F and perfect to produce variety of dishes.

If you are looking for a reasonably priced pan then Norpro stainless steel broiler pan [Buy On Amazon] is the best. Though it is not non stick; but this 12-inch broiler pan offers quick and even heat distribution to the food without compromising the food quality.

Frequently Asked Questions              

What are the Best Broiler Pans?

Norpro 274 stainless steel broiler pan [Buy On Amazon] is the best in the class of affordable range pans; however if you want to purchase a premium class broiler pan then Frigidaire Range Broiler Pan [Buy On Amazon] is the best broiler pan exists in premium pans.

What Pans are Safe for Broiling?

Some pans are mentioned as broiler safe or incase it is not mentioned then you can consider stainless steel broiler pan or cast iron broiler pan for your kitchen with durable non stick coating, that can able to withstand temperature up to 550F or more.

Can You Put Aluminum Foil in Broiler?

You can use aluminum foil in your broiler pan; they are quite helpful in prepping messy foods.

There is no technique required all you need is to make some kitchenette linings or markings in the aluminum foil and place it on the top and bottom parts of your broiler; the cut slits helps to drain out excess fats and oil from the food.

Try to avoid cooking acidic food with aluminum foil as they can absorb layers of aluminum into food.

That is the reason why experts suggest not to use aluminum foil instead they recommend glassware or porcelain ware baking dishes.

Can I use Broiler Pan in Oven?

Broiler pan is used for cooking or roasting meat, poultry, seafood, and vegetables. 

Using broiler pan adds convenience for marinating and sealing foods with different sauces and spices while extracting excess fat or oil.

A broiling pan is also known as oven roaster, oven broiling pan; and is used to make roasts, steaks, sea food, meat or poultry dishes, even various vegetable foods in the oven as well.

The difference between an oven and the broiler is that in oven the heat surround the foodto cook while in the broiler the heat gets into the food from the above which is considered good for toasting or browning foods such as  wholemeat, turkeys, chickens, pies or casseroles.

Can you use a broiler pan as a roasting pan?

Typically a broiler pan doesn’t have high sides though it do have a rack to collect the drippings; but if you get a broiler pan that is 9 to 13 inches in size with raised sides high enough to catch the juices or fats of the meat that drips while cooking then it can be used as a roasting pan.